Proof That Politicians Cannot Represent You (r Views)

The very short story of democratic representation

So what’s the problem?

Figure 1. The simple story of democratic representation.
The impossibility of democratic representation. Image credit: Shutterstock.

Why pro-life/pro-choice is not good enough

Figure 2. Simplified comprehensive view on abortion. (Encircled numbers represent pieces of knowledge.)
Table 1. Expected distribution for abortion support when the woman’s health is seriously endangered.
Table 2. Real distribution for abortion support when the woman’s health is seriously endangered.

Conclusion

Where does it leave us and why is this important?

  1. We can start improving representation by facilitating the acquisition of complex policy views by more and more people. This admirable undertaking could not only promote deep critical thinking but would likely help us keep politicians more accountable. While I think we should definitely pursue this goal, it will likely take a lot of time and effort with no guarantee for success. In the meantime, there’s a much simpler solution.
  2. If we can’t improve representation, why not give it up? There is more than one way to run a democracy. Instead of having politicians represent our views, why not simply put the the best people in positions of power to make the best decisions for all of us!

--

--

--

A political scientist (Ph.D.) and social psychologist (MA) fighting for a better world the only way I know how: on the battlefield of idea(l)s.

Love podcasts or audiobooks? Learn on the go with our new app.

Recommended from Medium

What a journey this has been…

National Identity in a Globalized Society

“America, Again” | Chapter 1: IOWA

The Domestic Threat to Peaceful Presidential Transitions

What Medium Reveals about Trump’s Transition Out of Office

Liberty’s Last Gasp

Mandatory Service Can Solve the U.S. Military’s Extremism Problem

Biden, Harris Meet With Asian American Community in Atlanta

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Balazs Feher-Gavra

Balazs Feher-Gavra

A political scientist (Ph.D.) and social psychologist (MA) fighting for a better world the only way I know how: on the battlefield of idea(l)s.

More from Medium

I have a practical solution to the world’s problems

Why it’s hard to feel for Ukraine

American ‘Exceptionalism?’ Yes, but Not in a Good Way

Aristotle’s View of Democracy & Government